How to adjudicate criminal records after the EEOC rescission: a guide for employers

The EEOC withdrew its 2012 guidance on arrest and conviction records on Oct. 29, 2026, but employers still have to apply criminal history consistently, tie it to the job, and follow the notice steps in the FCRA and in state and local law. A background report tells you what a record shows. Adjudication is your decision about whether that record matters for a specific role. This guide gives you a sequence for making that decision.

What the EEOC changed, and what it did not

The EEOC announced that it rescinded its Enforcement Guidance on the Consideration of Arrest and Conviction Records in Employment Decisions, effective immediately. The agency said the change does not give employers license to discriminate, and that Title VII still prohibits race and national origin discrimination, including requirements that act as proxies for intentional discrimination.

Two things stay the same. Title VII’s ban on treating applicants differently because of a protected characteristic is unchanged, and so is the law that private plaintiffs can use. Employers also remain subject to state and local rules on when you can ask about criminal history, how you assess it, and what notice you owe a candidate. Law firms tracking the change recommend reviewing existing policies rather than removing safeguards in a hurry.

Step 1: Separate what the report shows from what you may use

A screening report is a starting point. VICTIG reports pending charges and convictions, along with active non-adjudication dispositions such as deferrals and diversion programs while the applicant is still within the program. VICTIG does not report arrests that did not lead to a conviction. Misdemeanor convictions are reported for 10 years from the file date, or less where state law sets a shorter limit. Felony convictions are reported with no time limit, except in states with stricter rules, such as California, New York and Washington. If your hiring policy calls for a shorter lookback, such as five years, you can ask VICTIG in writing to apply it.

For more on how records are reported, see our guides on arrests on background checks and what a disposition means.

Step 2: Write the criteria before you review a single record

Decide in advance how you will weigh a record, and apply the same standard to every candidate for the same role. Most employers start with three questions that the 2012 guidance drew from case law:

  1. Nature and gravity. What was the offense, and how serious was it?
  2. Time passed. How long ago was the offense or the end of the sentence?
  3. Nature of the job. Does the offense relate to the duties, the setting, or the people the employee would work with?

The rescission removed the guidance, not the court decisions behind these factors, so they remain a practical way to show that an exclusion is job-related. Keep a short written note of how each answer led to your decision. Our guide to negligent hiring covers why careful, documented decisions matter on the other side of the risk.

Step 3: Check whether local law adds steps

Some states and cities require an individualized assessment, limit when you can ask about criminal history, or restrict certain records. Fair chance laws in Minneapolis and Washington State, both adopted in 2025, are examples of rules that the EEOC change does not affect. Check the rules for every location where you hire. Our ban-the-box state guide is a good place to start.

Step 4: Send the notices in order

If a report may lead you to reject a candidate or rescind an offer, the FCRA sets a two-step process:

  1. Pre-adverse action notice. Send the candidate a copy of the report and the FCRA Summary of Rights before you decide.
  2. Waiting period. Give the candidate a reasonable time to review the report and dispute anything inaccurate. Many employers allow at least five business days.
  3. Adverse action notice. If you still decide to reject, send a final notice that includes the screening company’s contact details and the candidate’s right to dispute.

If the candidate disputes the report, hold your decision until the screening company finishes its reinvestigation. Some local laws add their own notice or response requirements, so confirm them before you finalize. Our guide to FCRA-compliant screening services covers the broader requirements.

Step 5: Keep a record and review it

Save your written criteria, each assessment, and the notices you sent. Review your criteria at least once a year, and again when federal, state or local rules change. Consistent records are your best evidence that decisions were based on the job, not on a protected characteristic.

Where VICTIG fits

VICTIG is a PBSA-accredited screening company with U.S.-based support and a 1.8-day average turnaround across all searches. Our team can apply a lookback period that matches your policy and answer questions about how a record was reported. Clients can also choose to have VICTIG generate pre-adverse and adverse action notices. See our criminal background checks, or talk to our team about setting up your screening policy.

Frequently asked questions

Did the EEOC rescission make it legal to reject anyone with a record?

No. Title VII still prohibits discrimination, and state and local laws still apply. The EEOC withdrew guidance, not the underlying law.

Do I still need an individualized assessment?

It depends on where you hire. Some states and cities require one, and it remains a practical way to show a decision was job-related.

Does VICTIG report arrests that did not lead to a conviction?

No. VICTIG reports pending charges, convictions, and active non-adjudication dispositions such as deferrals and diversion programs.

How far back does a criminal search go?

Misdemeanor convictions are reported for 10 years from the file date, or less where state law is stricter. Felony convictions have no time limit except in states with stricter rules. You can ask in writing for a shorter lookback.

What notices must I send before rejecting a candidate?

A pre-adverse action notice with a copy of the report and the FCRA Summary of Rights, a reasonable waiting period, then a final adverse action notice.

Can VICTIG make the hiring decision for me?

No. VICTIG reports what a record shows. The decision to hire is yours, and it should follow written, job-related criteria.

Background Check Solutions

VICTIG provides quick turnaround times and easy-to-use technology.


Elite Client Support

Our highly-trained, award-winning customer support team is here for you.

Client Support